Post by zaira on Nov 11, 2005 2:56:16 GMT -5
missangelic69 said:
i don't agree,voice is not most important,i know she has unique voice but she is not the only opera-metal singer.True,its going to be strange without her but at least they saved band from breaking up..she wasnt't part of that band anymore anyway...and i think Tuomas just had to write that,for all their fans like explanation,as he said,they haven't talk for year..that's horrible,i understand his reasons,as a fan you have the full explanation of such a BIG decision
Yes and no, because for me, the voice must be good, just like the music. Of course their music is great and it won't change with the voice of another artist, but it' s not the same as before... I'm accustomed to Tarja's voice, I think.
In my opinion, a new talented singer will surely be bodacious in what she is going to sing with the band in future, but if she sings the old songs, which Tarja sang, it won't suit. Just because of Tarja's unique voice and the fact, that we fans listened to them too many times. But I agree with you, that Tuomas has done the best for the band - he says that he had no other choice and I'm sure, it wasn't easy for him to make this decision after being bandmates for 9 years.
It's sad that they are breaking up in dispute.
true,it's very sad...and yeah,you're right..old song with new voice are going to be kinda weird to listen,but seems like this change in band was unnecessary and we have to accept that,and new singer as well..of course for those who liked Tarja more than Nightwish (as a band) is this simply end of te band